Crispijn van den Broeck (Mechelen 1524-1590 Antwerp)
Lot 100

Crispijn van den Broeck (Mechelen 1524-1590 Antwerp)

The Choice between the Spirit and the Flesh

Closed10 December 2014

Price Realised

EUR 16,250

More Information

How to sell

Crispijn van den Broeck (Mechelen 1524-1590 Antwerp)
The Choice between the Spirit and the Flesh
dated '1576'
black chalk, pen and brown ink, brown wash, indented and reddened on the verso for transfer, brown ink framing lines
7 3/8 x 10 1/8 in. (18.6 x 25.5 cm.)

Paul Fabre (b. circa 1879), his mounter's mark (L. 958).
Unidentified collector's mark (L. 2707).
with Grosjean, Paris; from whom purchased by I.Q. van Regteren Altena on 25 January 1931 for 12.50 (Inventory book: '1052. C. v. d. Broeck allegorie').

Specialist note

This complex and remarkable allegory depicts the moral choice facing mankind. The figure of Man sits beneath a tree, hands folded in prayer, while a putto descends from above with the laurel crown and palm of Christian salvation. Flanking Man are the figures of Vita (Life) and Mors (Death). With her Bible and Crucifix, Vita represents the eternal life offered by the New Testament, while Mors is shown with the Tablets of the Law, suggesting that he represents the pre-Christian Old Testament. Yet the allegory does not just show Man torn between the Old Law and the New: in the foreground, allegorical figures representing Spiritus (the human spirit) and Charitas (Charity) struggle against personifications of Caro (carnal lust, decked out in a headdress of peacock feathers) and Mundum (the earthly world, with transient riches at her feet and a globe headdress). In the background, beyond Caro and Mundum, a ship founders in a gale, while beyond Spiritus and Charitas a lighthouse stands steadfast, offering a further hint at the prospects offered by each way of life.


Fig. 1. Johann Sadeler I, The choice between the Spirit and the Flesh, Amsterdam, Rijksmuseum.